Digital agriculture is typically hailed as an nearly magical set off for selling profitable farming, even amongst smallholder farmers in the growing world.
Its proponents argue that utilizing digital instruments to, for example, generate data and calendar schedules, may also help farmers develop higher crops, handle their assets extra effectively, and join with organised markets, all whereas decreasing post-harvest losses.
However not all researchers are satisfied that digital options are the reply to farmers’ issues. Some argue that the hype round these instruments diverts consideration from the true, on-the-ground challenges farmers face.
One Kenyan avocado farmer, talking to a researcher in 2021, mentioned: “We don’t want one other app.” Moderately, he mentioned: “Crates! We’d like crates to keep away from our avocados getting smashed on the best way to the customer.”
Kenya has turn into a very ripe marketplace for digital agriculture instruments. The nation, considered one of Africa’s main expertise hubs, has been labelled the “Silicon Savannah”. Eighty % of its roughly 4.5 million smallholder farmers personal cellphones and function inside Kenya’s properly established cell cash ecosystem.
Learn extra:
Digital options are boosting agriculture in Kenya, however it is time to scale up. This is how
We’re researchers in agricultural economics. In a current examine we examined Kenya’s digital agriculture panorama to see what options have been accessible and whether or not these have been addressing farmers’ actual challenges.
We took a list of all of the digital agriculture instruments listed in Google’s Play Retailer, assessing the expertise and providers supplied by these instruments with info from their very own homepages. Some are telephone apps; others are improvements whose {hardware} could be mounted onto farm equipment or are standalone devices like handheld scanners. We additionally studied peer-reviewed articles and studies to see the place such instruments had documented impacts, with a specific deal with Kenya.
We discovered that, over the previous decade, the variety of digital instruments accessible to smallholder farmers has vastly elevated. These instruments have, as documented within the literature we reviewed, helped farmers (in Kenya and elsewhere) enhance their data, entry markets, and boosting productiveness and revenue.
Nevertheless, higher integration of digital options with conventional farming practices is essential. Subject specialists should help farmers in making use of digital recommendation and supply hands-on steerage. Moreover, combining these options with native data, cultural practices and market improvement will make them more practical and helpful for farmers.
What instruments can be found to farmers?
Investing in agriculture is likely one of the quickest and only methods to cut back poverty, guarantee meals safety, and remodel the economies of growing nations’ rural areas.
However in Kenya, as in lots of different African nations, farmers wrestle with low agricultural productiveness. It’s as much as 5 occasions decrease than the worldwide common.
One of many causes is proscribed agricultural providers, corresponding to extension providers. These providers provide technical recommendation and help and assist farmers to entry the inputs they want for manufacturing, like fertilisers and seeds. In Kenya, there’s solely one extension agent per 1,200 farmers. Farmers wrestle to entry top quality seeds and fertilisers.
Many digital agriculture instruments promise to resolve these points.
In our examine we discovered that the variety of digital instruments accessible to farmers in Kenya had tripled over the previous decade, from 17 in 2013 to 52 in 2023.
The event of those instruments surged in 2016 however has slowed down not too long ago. This can be as a result of market saturation and a deal with enhancing current instruments. There’s a shift from instruments that provide normal farming info (which is also present in textual content books or advisory materials) to “farm-specific” instruments. These offered personalised recommendation based mostly on farm or livestock-specific knowledge that farmers both entered manually or was collected digitally by sensors.
Some examples of apps embrace iShamba, which offers info and allows studying for farmers, and the AgroCares Scanner, providing recommendation on soil well being based mostly on farm-specific testing. One other is DigiFarm, which connects farmers with monetary providers.
Most of those instruments are developed by personal corporations, although some work with public extension providers. Many are designed for farmers with smartphones. Others depend on characteristic telephones or use intermediaries to attach much less tech-savvy farmers with the providers they want.
How do digital instruments handle farmers’ challenges?
The literature overview a part of the examine allowed us to establish a number of methods digital options can and do assist farmers in Kenya.
Nevertheless, digital agriculture instruments’ impact on meals safety and the setting stays unclear.
What’s lacking?
The effectiveness of farm-specific options depends upon correct and dependable knowledge. Challenges like restricted entry to smartphones and knowledge, in addition to digital literacy, have to be addressed.
We additionally discovered that few instruments explicitly goal sustainable practices or provide local weather adaptation options. Integrating metrics like water use effectivity and soil well being into digital platforms may also help farmers make eco-friendly selections, and adapt to climate associated dangers. Governments and businesses might incentivise such climate-resilient practices by means of digital platforms.
There are additionally gaps in understanding the long-term results of digital instruments on farm productiveness, meals safety and environmental sustainability.
Lastly, complete and rigorous evaluations are wanted to know the complete impact of those instruments: their usability, affordability, and the way straightforward it’s to combine them with current farming practices.
