If we abide by the frequent definition of philosophy because the love of knowledge, and if Montaigne was proper that philosophy is the artwork of studying to die, then residing properly is the artwork of studying how you’ll want to have lived. A type of decision in reverse.
That is the place the knowledge of lives which have already been lived could be of immense assist — a supply of forward-facing resolutions, borrowed from individuals who have lengthy died, having lived, by any cheap customary, honorable and beneficiant lives, lives of magnificence and substance, irradiated by concepts which have endured throughout the epochs to make different lives extra livable.
Listed here are ten such concepts (after many extra highlighted in years previous) that make for life-expanding resolutions, and an additional eleventh as an overarching ethos.
HANNAH ARENDT: LOVE WITHOUT FEAR OF LOSS
We are going to lose all the pieces we love, together with our lives — so we would as effectively love with out worry, for to worry a certainty is wasted power that syphons lifetime of aliveness.
Lengthy earlier than she turned America’s preeminent thinker, having arrived as a refugee, Hannah Arendt (October 14, 1906–December 4, 1975) was a younger Jewish girl in Nazi-inflamed Germany, in love with an unbelievable beloved, writing a doctoral thesis about love that is still her least recognized however most soulful work: Love and Saint Augustine (public library) — an beautiful meditation on love and learn how to stay with the basic worry of loss.
Tracing Saint Augustine’s debt to the Stoics, Arendt considers how our attachment to the phantasm of permanence and safety limits our lives, and writes:
Of their worry of dying, these residing worry life itself, a life that’s doomed to die… The mode by which life is aware of and perceives itself is fear. Thus the item of worry involves be worry itself. Even when we should always assume that there’s nothing to worry, that dying is not any evil, the very fact of worry (that each one residing issues shun dying) stays.
[…]
Fearlessness is what love seeks. Love as craving is set by its aim, and this aim is freedom from worry… Such fearlessness exists solely within the full calm that may now not be shaken by occasions anticipated of the longer term… Therefore the one legitimate tense is the current, the Now.
TONI MORRISON: CHERISH YOUR BODY
Partway in time between Walt Whitman’s declamation that “the physique… is the that means, the principle concern and consists of and is the soul,” and its affirmation by fashionable neuroscience, which is revealing how the feeling-tone of the physique scores the symphony of consciousness, Toni Morrison (February 18, 1931–August 5, 2019) serenaded the unselfconscious physique because the supreme instrument of self-regard — the deepest place the place the assertion “I rejoice myself” begins.
In her 1987 masterpiece Beloved (public library) — which made her the primary author ensouled in a physique with black pores and skin and XX chromosomes to obtain the Nobel Prize — she writes:
Love your palms! Love them. Increase them up and kiss them. Contact others with them, pat them collectively, stroke them in your face… Love your mouth… That is flesh… Flesh that must be cherished. Toes that have to relaxation and to bop; backs that want help; shoulders that want arms, robust arms… Love your neck; put a hand on it, grace it, stroke it and maintain it up. And all of your inside elements that they’d simply as quickly slop for hogs, you bought to like them. The darkish, darkish liver — find it irresistible, find it irresistible, and the beat and beating coronary heart, love that too. Greater than eyes or toes. Greater than lungs which have but to attract free air. Greater than your life-holding womb and your life-giving non-public elements… love your coronary heart. For that is the prize.
VIKTOR FRANKL: HAVE MORE MUSIC AND NATURE IN YOUR LIFE
A century after Nietzsche proclaimed together with his nihilistic grandiosity that “with out music life can be a mistake” and a century after Walt Whitman noticed together with his life-affirming soulfulness that music is the profoundest expression of nature, the younger Viennese neurologist and psychiatrist Viktor Frankl (March 26, 1905–September 2, 1997), having narrowly escaped dying in a focus camp, delivered a set of extraordinary lectures on shifting past optimism and pessimism to search out the deepest supply of that means. A misplaced companion to his basic Man’s Seek for Which means, these lectures had been solely not too long ago printed in English for the primary time underneath the apt title, drawn from a line of Frankl’s, Sure to Life: In Spite of Every thing (public library).
In one in every of them, Frankl speaks with passionate life-tested conviction to the 2 nice pillars of aliveness that had helped him survive the Holocaust and that assist so many people, even in circumstances far much less life-threatening, survive our lives — music and the pure world:
It’s not solely by our actions that we may give life that means — insofar as we will reply life’s particular questions responsibly — we will fulfill the calls for of existence not solely as energetic brokers but additionally as loving human beings: in our loving dedication to the gorgeous, the good, the great. Ought to I maybe attempt to clarify for you with some hackneyed phrase how and why experiencing magnificence could make life significant? I favor to restrict myself to the next thought experiment: think about that you’re sitting in a live performance corridor and listening to your favourite symphony, and your favourite bars of the symphony resound in your ears, and you’re so moved by the music that it sends shivers down your backbone; and now think about that it might be doable (one thing that’s psychologically so unattainable) for somebody to ask you on this second whether or not your life has that means. I consider you’d agree with me if I declared that on this case you’d solely be capable to give one reply, and it might go one thing like: “It could have been price it to have lived for this second alone!”
Greater than a century after Mary Shelley celebrated nature as a lifeline to sanity and survival in a world savaged by a lethal pandemic, Frankl provides:
Those that expertise, not the humanities, however nature, might have the same response, and likewise those that expertise one other human being. Will we not know the sensation that overtakes us once we are within the presence of a selected particular person and, roughly interprets as, The truth that this particular person exists on this planet in any respect, this alone makes this world, and a life in it, significant.
LEO TOLSTOY: CHOOSE KINDNESS
One of many saddest tendencies in our current tradition is an indignant intolerance for the fundamental humanity of being human. Folks of the previous are harshly judged by the requirements of the current (which their very own tough lives helped set up), and folks of the current are harshly judged by unattainable (and hypocritical, within the full context of any judger’s life) requirements of uniform perfection throughout all areas of personal and public existence. And but the everlasting take a look at of character — our nice ethical triumph — is the flexibility to face our personal imperfections with composure, reflecting on them with lucid and luminous willpower to do higher — a vital type of ethical braveness all of the harder, and all of the extra vital, amid a cultural environment that errors self-righteousness for morality and suffocates the fundamental impulse towards betterment with punitive intolerance for human foible.
Fortunately for Leo Tolstoy (September 9, 1828–November 20, 1910), and fortuitously for the generations of people whose lives have been enriched and ennobled by his contribution to the frequent document of reality and wonder we name literature, he lived in a really totally different period. When he was approaching that period’s life-expectancy — which he would come to survive almost twofold — Tolstoy started reckoning together with his personal imperfect life, punctuated by the human inevitability of getting acted unwisely and unlovingly in moments too mentally and emotionally threadbare to behave in any other case, and got down to discover the knowledge he had lacked alongside the way in which.
So started his Calendar of Knowledge: Day by day Ideas to Nourish the Soul, Written and Chosen from the World’s Sacred Texts (public library) — a compendium of quotations by nice thinkers of the previous, annotated with Tolstoy’s personal ideas, which he compiled for twenty years and printed within the last ailing years of his life. (In some deep but apparent sense, The Marginalian is my very own lifelong model of such a compendium, commenced lengthy earlier than I first encountered Tolstoy’s ebook a decade in the past.)
Within the entry for January 7 — maybe prompted by the creaturely severity and the heart-clenching bleakness of a Russian winter, or maybe by the renewed resolve for ethical betterment with which we face every new 12 months — he writes:
The kinder and the extra considerate an individual is, the extra kindness he can discover in different folks.
Kindness enriches our life; with kindness mysterious issues develop into clear, tough issues develop into simple, and uninteresting issues develop into cheerful.
On the finish of the month, in a sentiment Carl Sagan would come to echo in his beautiful invitation to satisfy ignorance with kindness, Tolstoy writes:
It is best to reply with kindness towards evil carried out to you, and you’ll destroy in an evil individual that pleasure which he derives from evil.
Within the first days of February — the shortest, bleakest month, recognized in our a part of the world as “the Little Ripper” — Tolstoy copies out two kindness-related quotations from Jeremy Bentham and John Ruskin, then displays:
Kindness is on your soul as well being is on your physique: you don’t discover it when you’ve it.
[…]
Nothing could make our life, or the lives of different folks, extra stunning than perpetual kindness.
JAMES BALDWIN: HAVE TENDERNESS FOR HOW HARD IT IS TO BE HUMAN
Throughout epochs and cultures, in his well-known indictment “it has at all times been a lot simpler (as a result of it has at all times appeared a lot safer) to offer a reputation to the evil with out than to find the fear inside,” James Baldwin (August 2, 1924–December 1, 1987) shone his piercing beam of reality upon the basic truth beneath Tolstoy’s perception that we solely see as a lot kindness as we ourselves possess: We’re untender with one another as a result of we can’t bear the terrifying issue of being human, weak and perishable as we’re.
And but, like Tolstoy, Baldwin thought deeply about what saves us — from ourselves and, in consequence, from one another — and, like Tolstoy, he acknowledged that, ultimately, solely love does. In his lifeline for the hour of despair — which stays one in every of his most penetrating and most private essays, and one in every of his least recognized — he observes:
I’ve at all times felt {that a} human being might solely be saved by one other human being. I’m conscious that we don’t save one another fairly often. However I’m additionally conscious that we save one another a few of the time.
Within the last essay from the identical forgotten treasure, Baldwin revisits the topic in what can finest be described as a prose poem of everlasting reality:
The earth is at all times shifting, the sunshine is at all times altering, the ocean doesn’t stop to grind down rock. Generations don’t stop to be born, and we’re accountable to them as a result of we’re the one witnesses they’ve.
The ocean rises, the sunshine fails, lovers cling to one another, and youngsters cling to us. The second we stop to carry one another, the second we break religion with each other, the ocean engulfs us and the sunshine goes out.
However to carry one another within the religion of affection is not any small triumph for our fear-frayed hearts. In one in every of his last interviews, echoing Rilke’s insistence that “for one human being to like one other: that’s maybe probably the most tough of all our duties,” Baldwin displays:
Loving anyone and being cherished by anyone is an amazing hazard, an amazing accountability.
And but, as he informed Margaret Mead of their historic dialog, it’s a accountability to our personal humanity:
We’ve bought to be as clear-headed about human beings as doable, as a result of we’re nonetheless one another’s solely hope.
RACHEL CARSON: EMBRACE THE LONELINESS OF CREATIVE WORK
“Artistic endeavors are of an infinite loneliness,” Rilke wrote in reflecting on the lonely endurance of artistic work — endurance wanted not solely in artwork however in each realm of creativity, together with science, and maybe nowhere extra so than on the unusual intersection of the 2.
In her unexampled union of artwork and science, the marine biologist and poetic nature-writer Rachel Carson (Could 27, 1907–April 14, 1964) neither romanticized nor rued the important loneliness of artistic absorption. As a substitute, she addressed it with the plain poetics of her lived expertise.
Even after her lyrical writing in regards to the science of the ocean gained her the nation’s highest honor of literary artwork and her 1962 ebook Silent Spring catalyzed the environmental motion, making her the period’s most revered science author, Carson continued making time to reply to letters from readers. On this superhuman feat — one downright unattainable in our age of electronic mail, when tens of millions of readers can attain a single author’s inbox with the unmediated faucet of a digital button — Carson hauled trunkfuls of letters residence, prioritizing these from college students and younger ladies asking her recommendation on writing. Responding to one in every of them, she provided:
Writing is a lonely occupation at finest. After all there are stimulating and even completely satisfied associations with mates and colleagues, however in the course of the precise work of creation the author cuts himself off from all others and confronts his topic alone. He* strikes right into a realm the place he has by no means been earlier than — maybe the place nobody has ever been. It’s a lonely place, even slightly scary.
In one other letter, writing to a younger girl in whom Carson noticed her youthful self, she deepens and broadens the sentiment:
You’re clever sufficient to grasp that being “slightly lonely” isn’t a foul factor. A author’s occupation is without doubt one of the loneliest on this planet, even when the loneliness is simply an interior solitude and isolation, for that he should have at occasions if he’s to be actually artistic. And so I consider solely the one who is aware of and isn’t afraid of loneliness ought to aspire to be a author. However there are additionally rewards which can be wealthy and peculiarly satisfying.
URSULA Ok. LE GUIN: CONVERSE IF YOU CARE
Let me be clear that no a part of me idealizes the bygone agony of ready three weeks for a letter out of your lover to cross the Atlantic — a letter that may by no means arrive from a lover who is perhaps useless by the point it does arrive. However let me even be clear that, in one other century or two, if humanity is sensible sufficient to outlive and rethink its compulsions, posterity will look again on us gobsmacked that we put ourselves by the agony of the three pulsating dots.
It’s arduous sufficient for one consciousness to speak itself to a different even with each epistolary, verbal, and gestural language now we have. It’s borderline unattainable with solely probably the most expressionless and tenorless instrument at hand. Texting, with its ready-made emojis and its immediacy, is an excellent medium for communication of levity and logistics. However the place it triumphs in time-sensitive issues, it fails abysmally in issues of emotional sensitivity — I don’t know of a single relationship that has been improved, repaired, or saved by texting in these important and weak moments of emotional misalignment and miscommunication, the place the medium’s immediacy turns into a gauntlet of mutual reactivity and its two-way disembodiment a means of avoiding the proof of 1’s emotional impression on the opposite. Right here, dialog triumphs. Right here, I’m at all times reminded of Ursula Ok. Le Guin (October 21, 1929–January 22, 2018) and her beautiful manifesto for the facility of actual human communication, by which she writes:
Generally of individuals truly speaking to 1 one other, human communication can’t be diminished to info. The message not solely entails, it is, a relationship between speaker and hearer. The medium by which the message is embedded is immensely complicated, infinitely greater than a code: it’s a language, a operate of a society, a tradition, by which the language, the speaker, and the hearer are all embedded.
Reminding us that literacy is an extremely nascent invention and nonetheless removed from common, Le Guin considers the singular and immutable energy of spoken dialog in fostering a profound mutuality by syncing our important vibrations:
Speech connects us so instantly and vitally as a result of it’s a bodily, bodily course of, to start with. Not a psychological or religious one, wherever it could finish… The voice creates a sphere round it, which incorporates all its hearers: an intimate sphere or space, restricted in each house and time.
Creation is an act. Motion takes power.
Sound is dynamic. Speech is dynamic — it’s motion. To behave is to take energy, to have energy, to be highly effective. Mutual communication between audio system and listeners is a robust act. The ability of every speaker is amplified, augmented, by the entrainment of the listeners. The power of a group is amplified, augmented by its mutual entrainment in speech.
[…]
Because of this utterance is magic. Phrases do have energy. Names have energy. Phrases are occasions, they do issues, change issues. They rework each speaker and hearer; they feed power backwards and forwards and amplify it. They feed understanding or emotion backwards and forwards and amplify it.
SENECA: VANQUISH YOUR ANXIETY
Two millennia earlier than the scientific idea of hysteria was coined, the good Roman Stoic thinker Seneca (c. 4 BC–AD 65) provided a timeless salve for this elemental human anguish in his correspondence together with his pal Lucilius Junior, later printed as Letters from a Stoic (public library).
Within the thirteenth letter, titled “On groundless fears,” Seneca writes:
There are extra issues … more likely to frighten us than there are to crush us; we undergo extra usually in creativeness than in actuality.
With a watch to the self-defeating and wearying human behavior of bracing ourselves for imaginary catastrophe, Seneca counsels his younger pal:
What I counsel you to do is, to not be sad earlier than the disaster comes; since it could be that the hazards earlier than which you paled as in the event that they had been threatening you, won’t ever come across you; they actually haven’t but come.
Accordingly, some issues torment us greater than they ought; some torment us earlier than they ought; and a few torment us once they ought to not torment us in any respect. We’re within the behavior of exaggerating, or imagining, or anticipating, sorrow.
However the biggest peril of misplaced fear, Seneca cautions, is that in consistently bracing for an imagined disaster, we hold ourselves from absolutely residing — one thing on which he expounded in his most well-known ethical essay, On the Shortness of Life. He ends the letter with a quote from Epicurus illustrating this sobering level:
The idiot, with all his different faults, has this additionally, he’s at all times on the brink of stay.
BERTRAND RUSSELL: BROADEN YOUR LIFE AS IT GROWS SHORTER
Two millennia after Seneca made his basic case for combating the shortness of life by residing broadly, the good British thinker, mathematician, historian, and Nobel laureate Bertrand Russell (Could 18, 1872–February 2, 1970) seemed again on his eight a long time of life — not but realizing that he would stay for almost two extra — to look at what makes it price residing.
In a brief meditation titled “How you can Develop Previous,” later included in his altogether very good Portraits from Reminiscence and Different Essays (public library), Russell locations on the coronary heart of a satisfying life the dissolution of the private ego into one thing bigger. Drawing on the longstanding attract of rivers as existential metaphors, he writes:
Make your pursuits regularly wider and extra impersonal, till little by little the partitions of the ego recede, and your life turns into more and more merged within the common life. A person human existence ought to be like a river — small at first, narrowly contained inside its banks, and dashing passionately previous rocks and over waterfalls. Step by step the river grows wider, the banks recede, the waters circulation extra quietly, and ultimately, with none seen break, they develop into merged within the sea, and painlessly lose their particular person being.
WALT WHITMAN: LIVE WITH ABSOLUTE ALIVENESS
Walt Whitman (Could 31, 1819–March 26, 1892) was solely thirty-six when he self-published, towards a tide of indifference ruffled by a couple of mocking evaluations, what would develop into his younger nation’s first nice basic of authentic poetry.
Within the preface to the primary version of Leaves of Grass (public library | public area), penned a long time earlier than a paralytic stroke reaffirmed his credo of aliveness, the Brooklyn poet encapsulated in radiant prose the guiding spirit of his poems — an ethos sure to broaden and gladden any life at any stage in any period:
That is what you shall do: Love the earth and solar and the animals, despise riches, give alms to each one which asks, get up for the silly and loopy, dedicate your revenue and labor to others, hate tyrants, argue not regarding God, have endurance and indulgence towards the folks, take off your hat to nothing recognized or unknown or to any man or variety of males, go freely with highly effective uneducated individuals and with the younger and with the moms of households, learn these leaves within the open air each season of yearly of your life, re-examine all you’ve been informed in school or church or in any ebook, dismiss no matter insults your personal soul, and your very flesh shall be an incredible poem and have the richest fluency not solely in its phrases however within the silent traces of its lips and face and between the lashes of your eyes and in each movement and joint of your physique.
AND ONE FROM ME: CHOOSE THE EYES OF LOVE
What we see is rarely uncooked actuality, pure as spacetime — what we see is our interpretation of actuality, filtered by the lens of our expertise and our conditioned worldview. All the time, the way in which we take a look at issues shapes what we see; usually, the lens we mistake for a magnifying glass seems to be a warped mirror — we see others not as they’re however as we’re. (We all know this the way in which the human animal finest understands something — by turning selfward: Everyone knows that horrible, hollowing feeling of being seen by one other not as we’re however as they’re, being achingly misunderstood and misinterpreted in our motives and the core of our being.)
It’s a service to actuality to see with larger charity of interpretation. It’s a service to different human beings to take a look at them, confused and self-concerned as they might be, with the eyes of affection and to withstand for so long as doable letting the cataract of judgment occlude our view.
To put the want to perceive above the want to be proper — and to see, with Thich Nhat Hanh, that “understanding is love’s different identify” — that’s the biggest reward we may give each other.
